Listen up idiot, MAGA is lying to you.
- Todd Schwartz

- Dec 16, 2025
- 3 min read
The phrase "MAGA is lying to you" might sound harsh, but it reflects a growing frustration with misinformation and false promises that have circulated under the Make America Great Again banner. Many people have bought into narratives that don’t hold up under scrutiny. This post will unpack some of the most common claims made by MAGA supporters, reveal the facts behind them, and explain why believing these lies can be harmful to individuals and the country.

The False Promise of Economic Revival
One of the biggest claims made by MAGA supporters is that the movement will restore the American economy to its former glory. The slogan suggests a return to a time when jobs were plentiful, wages were high, and manufacturing thrived. But the reality is more complicated.
Job numbers can be misleading: While some sectors saw job growth during the MAGA era, many of these jobs were low-wage or part-time positions. For example, manufacturing jobs continued to decline due to automation and global competition.
Wage growth lagged behind inflation: Even when employment numbers improved, wage increases did not keep pace with rising costs of living. This means many workers actually lost purchasing power.
Trade wars hurt more than helped: Tariffs on imports were meant to protect American industries but often resulted in higher prices for consumers and retaliatory tariffs that hurt exporters.
These economic realities show that the promise of a booming economy under MAGA was more wishful thinking than fact.
The Myth of Border Security Success
Border security is another major talking point. MAGA rhetoric often paints a picture of a border under siege, with claims that illegal immigration is out of control and that the wall is the ultimate solution. The truth is more nuanced.
Illegal border crossings fluctuate: Data from the U.S. Customs and Border Protection shows that illegal crossings vary widely depending on economic conditions, violence in home countries, and policy changes. The situation is not a simple crisis.
The wall’s effectiveness is limited: Physical barriers can deter some crossings but do not stop determined migrants. Many enter through legal ports of entry or use other methods.
Immigration enforcement is complex: Policies that separate families or detain migrants have faced legal challenges and public backlash, showing that enforcement is not just about building walls.
Believing the oversimplified MAGA narrative about border security ignores the complexity of immigration and the human stories involved.
The Reality Behind Law and Order Claims
MAGA supporters often emphasize "law and order" as a key value, suggesting that crime rates soared under previous administrations and that their policies restored safety. This claim deserves a closer look.
Crime rates have fluctuated independently of political leadership: Crime trends depend on many factors including economic conditions, policing strategies, and social programs.
Some cities saw increases, others decreases: National crime statistics show mixed results. Some urban areas experienced rises in violent crime, while others saw declines.
Tough-on-crime policies have consequences: Aggressive policing and harsh sentencing can lead to mass incarceration, disproportionately affecting minority communities without necessarily improving public safety.
The simplistic "law and order" message ignores the complexity of crime and justice in America.
The Truth About Media and “Fake News”
MAGA rhetoric frequently attacks mainstream media, labeling unfavorable coverage as “fake news.” This tactic aims to discredit critics and create an alternate reality.
Media bias exists but is not uniform: Different outlets have different perspectives, but most adhere to journalistic standards.
Fact-checking organizations expose false claims: Many statements from MAGA leaders have been fact-checked and found to be misleading or false.
Distrust in media can harm democracy: When people reject credible information, it becomes harder to have informed public debates or hold leaders accountable.
Understanding media literacy is crucial to avoid falling for misinformation.

Why Believing These Lies Matters
Accepting false claims from any political movement has real consequences:
Polarization increases: When people believe different versions of reality, it becomes harder to find common ground.
Policy decisions suffer: Laws based on misinformation can cause harm, waste resources, or fail to address real problems.
Trust in institutions erodes: Democracy depends on trust in elections, courts, and the press. Undermining these weakens the system.
It is essential to question narratives, seek facts, and think critically about political messages.
What You Can Do
Check multiple sources: Don’t rely on a single news outlet or social media feed.
Look for evidence: Verify claims with data from reputable organizations.
Engage respectfully: Discuss politics with an open mind and listen to different viewpoints.
Stay informed: Follow updates from fact-checkers and experts.
Taking these steps helps protect yourself from misinformation and contributes to a healthier political environment.



